Betsy points us to an article by Stephen Budiansky about trying to write satire about our institutes of higher learning and finding that the institutes have been there before him…
Betsy quotes part of it as follows:
As a model of pandering to students in the guise of lofty academic purpose, I thought that was pretty hard to top. Then I started reading the 92-page guide Case has created for teachers of these seminars.
If students fidget, talk or walk out of class, the guide advises seminar leaders not to “manage” such behaviors, but to explore their underlying causes. Instructors must remember that to such characteristically American cultural beliefs as the importance of morality, rationality and personal responsibility, there are equally valid alternatives that must be respected.
Instructors must be wary of spurious objectivity, such as a 0-100 grading scale; much better is a 0-5 scale, or, best of all, a check, check-plus, check-minus scale. And finally, if students do not contribute to discussions at all, seminar leaders should “make space for silence.”
and comments on the “check, check-plus, and check-minus scale.”
Me, I latched onto the “If students fidget, talk or walk out of class, the guide advises seminar leaders not to “manage” such behaviors, but to explore their underlying causes.” part.
These students are going to get a very rude awakening when they exhibit this kind of behavior at their new places of employment.
New employee is attending a meeting at place of employment.
New employee fidgets, talks, plays solitare on laptop or pda, and then just gets up and leaves said meeting.
A short while later, new employee is now ex-employee.
All this “feel good”, self esteem is everything - forget about actually learning skills stuff is sooo not helpful to survival in the real world.
I commented over at Betsy’s site that this is another example of “the bigotry of soft expectations” and it’s not just racial either.
I know that a chain is only as strong as its weakest link, but when we continually work at making all the links weak instead of stronger we will all lose in the end.